HoursMonday to Friday 6:00am to 9:00pm, Saturday 6:00am to 11:00am

Text us
Spare keys and key problems

Spare keys, duplicates, broken keys, and ignition key problems

A spare made today costs a fraction of a key created after every key is gone. This is the one page on this site that is about spending a little now to avoid spending a lot later.

Not sure what you need? Start here.

Answer in plain words. This points you to the right service in about ten seconds.

Step 1

Would rather just talk to someone?

Skip the questions. A call sorts it in a minute.

(860) 574-1635
  • CT registered locksmithRegistration LCK.0000486
  • Insured locksmithWork done by an insured business
  • Upfront quote and ETABefore anyone is dispatched
  • Pay after the workOnly once the job is done
  • Family ownedLocal and accountable
  • Damage free entryOur standard method
Dante of Dante Key Replacement, in a branded work shirt, holding up a smart key fob from the doorway of a vehicle.
A spare made today is the cheapest key you will ever buy. Once every key is gone, the same vehicle costs considerably more.

Why a spare key is the cheapest key decision

Copying a key while you still hold a working one is the least expensive version of car key service, because the existing key provides both the cut and, on many vehicles, the authorization to add another key. Once every key is lost, the cut has to be generated from the vehicle and the immobilizer has to be accessed without an accepted key present. That is why the same vehicle costs substantially more to key after the last key disappears.

  • Two working keys, kept in different places. A spare in the same bag as the original solves nothing.
  • The gap is widest on push to start vehicles. Those are the strictest to key from nothing.
  • A worn key is a warning. Sticking or needing a wiggle means it is near the end.
Waiting until every key is gone
  • The cut has to be generated from the vehicle itself.
  • The immobilizer has to be accessed with no accepted key present.
  • Entry to the vehicle may be needed first.
  • Some manufacturers enforce a built in security wait period.
  • It happens on the worst possible day, usually somewhere inconvenient.
  • Some vehicles can only be done by a dealer, which adds a tow.

The best time to ask for a second key

If you are already having a key made after losing one, ask for a second during the same visit. The expensive part of that job is reaching the point where the vehicle accepts a key at all. Adding another once you are there is comparatively cheap, and it means you never repeat the process.

Broken keys

When a key snaps, stop before you make it worse

Most broken key jobs that turn into expensive lock replacements do so because of what happened in the ten minutes after the break.

Do this

  • Leave the broken piece exactly where it is.
  • Keep both halves, because they help identify the key.
  • Note whether the piece moved or turned as it broke.
  • Use another door or another key if you have one.

Do not do this

  • Do not push the other half in to try to turn it.
  • Do not use glue. This is the one that ruins cylinders.
  • Do not force tweezers or a screwdriver into the cylinder.
  • Do not keep trying the ignition once it has broken.

Ignition key problems

An ignition that will not turn is not always a key problem, and the difference matters because the jobs are priced very differently. The possibilities separate into a steering lock holding the cylinder, a worn key, a worn cylinder, or a fault in the ignition assembly itself.

Describing precisely what happens narrows it down before anyone drives out. Whether the key enters fully, whether it moves at all, and whether it had been working intermittently beforehand are the three details that identify the cause and decide what needs to be on the van.

Have this ready before you request service

Every item below either speeds the job up or decides whether it can be done at all. Having them ready at the start avoids a second trip.

  • The year, make, and model of the vehicle.
  • Whether you have any working key or fob left.
  • The exact location of the vehicle, including a lot, level, or row if it is in a garage.
  • Registration or title in your name, plus a photo ID that matches it.
  • Whether the vehicle is drivable and whether it is blocked in.

Signs your key is about to fail

Keys give warning before they break. These are the signals worth acting on while it is still a cheap problem.

  • It needs wiggling or jiggling to turn.
  • The teeth look visibly rounded compared with a spare.
  • It sticks on the way in or on the way out.
  • It has a visible bend, or you have straightened it before.
  • One door works and another has stopped.

If a spare exists and it works better than your daily key, that is the wear talking.

Cost

What decides the cost of a spare or a broken key job

Dante beside the Triton Plus key cutting machine and a key programming tablet, set up in the back of his service vehicle.
A spare is the cheapest key you will ever buy. Cutting from an existing key is a fraction of the work an all keys lost job takes.
  1. Tell us about the job

    The year, make, and model, whether any working key is left, and where the vehicle is parked.

  2. Get your quote and ETA upfront

    You hear the price for your exact vehicle or lock, and when to expect us, before anyone is dispatched.

  3. Pay when the work is done

    Nothing is paid up front. You pay once the job is finished and tested. Card, tap to pay, and cash are all accepted.

What changes the price

Key type
A basic mechanical key, a transponder key, a remote head key, and a proximity smart key are different parts with different costs.
Programming needs
Some vehicles accept a new key with on board programming. Others require a diagnostic tool and a security access process that takes longer.
How many keys are lost
Replacing a spare while you still hold a working key is a shorter job than an all keys lost situation, which needs the key cut from the vehicle code and the system reprogrammed.
Vehicle security level
Some manufacturers hold key data behind a secure gateway or a waiting period. That changes the time and the equipment required.
Location and access
A vehicle in an open driveway is quicker to work on than one in a tight garage bay or a lot that limits access.
Topical automotive cluster

Complete car key and vehicle lock solutions

Explore dedicated guides for every car key situation, key system, programming requirement, and vehicle make.

Spare & duplicate keys Current

Duplicate keys made before losing your only working key.

Mobile dispatch across Eastern Connecticut

We travel directly to your location in Norwich, New London, Groton, Colchester, and all 48 service towns.

Questions

Spare key and broken key questions

Dante smiling at the camera while working at a vehicle door with a slim entry tool.
Made while you wait, at your vehicle. A spare does not need a shop appointment or a second trip.

Financially it is one of the clearest decisions in this trade. Copying a key while you still hold a working one is the cheapest version of this service. Creating a key when every key is gone is the most expensive.

The gap is not small, and it is widest on push to start vehicles. A spare also removes the towing question entirely, because a vehicle with a spare key can always be driven.

For a plain mechanical key with no chip, yes, and it is the cheapest route. That covers many older vehicles and it is a perfectly sensible thing to do.

For anything with a chip it will not be enough. The blade will turn the door and the ignition and the engine will not start, because the immobilizer does not recognize an unprogrammed chip. A copied blade is half the job on any vehicle built since the late 1990s.

Stop trying to remove it. Forcing a broken piece deeper, or trying to hook it out with something rigid, is what turns a straightforward extraction into a lock or ignition replacement.

Leave it where it is, do not insert the other half, and describe exactly what happened when you request service. Say which lock it is in, how much is showing, and whether the piece moved when it broke.

Usually wear rather than a single bad moment. Keys and lock cylinders wear together over years, and a key that had started sticking, needing a wiggle, or requiring pressure to turn was already telling you it was near the end.

Worth knowing: if you copy a worn key, you copy the wear. A duplicate made from a badly worn original inherits its problems, which is why cutting a fresh key to the vehicle code sometimes works better than copying what you have.

At least two working keys in total is the practical answer, kept in different places. A spare in the same bag as the original solves nothing when the bag is what goes missing.

If more than one person drives the vehicle, one working key each plus a spare kept at home is the arrangement that avoids the most problems.

An ignition that will not turn has several possible causes, and they are genuinely different jobs at different prices. A steering lock holding the cylinder, a worn key, a worn cylinder, and a fault in the ignition assembly all feel similar from the driver seat.

Describe exactly what happens when you turn it and you get a straight answer about which one it is likely to be, and whether it is something we handle, before anyone drives out.

Get help now

Get a spare while it is still the cheap option

Send the year, make, and model, and say that you still have a working key. That is the shortest and least expensive version of this job.

Call or text with the vehicle or the property, the exact location, and what happened. You get an upfront quote and an arrival estimate before anyone is dispatched, and you pay only after the work is done.

Opening hours

HoursMonday to Friday 6:00am to 9:00pm, Saturday 6:00am to 11:00am

  • Monday to Friday 6:00am to 9:00pm
  • Saturday 6:00am to 11:00am
  • Sunday Closed

Outside these hours, emergency jobs are taken case by case and are not guaranteed. Call to confirm.

Payment: Card, tap to pay, or cash, taken once the work is done.

Call nowTextForm